
Episode 481: Don't Should On Yourself
Podcast accessible on: iTunes | Spotify | YouTube | tocculture.com
This time of year, a lot of coaches I talk with are carrying a list of things that should be different. The team should be further along. A player should know the play by now. A parent should understand how captains get picked. Most of us do not notice how much of our frustration starts with that one word.
In this roundtable, JP, Betsy, and Nate pull that word apart. They share the questions they use to test whether a should is even true, what to do when your expectations collide with a player's or a parent's, and how to feel frustration without letting it run the rest of your day.
If you want to keep your standards high without carrying the anger that so often comes with them, this conversation is worth your full attention.
TOC 3-2-1
3 Quotes | 2 Questions | 1 Resource - Your fast-track to the episode's most actionable ideas.
3 QUOTES WORTH WRITING DOWN
"The word should is kind of like the trapdoor that reveals a whole lot underneath of it if you're willing to explore it."
- Nate Sanderson
"Oftentimes we carry our own expectations of others that we're not living up to ourselves."
- JP Nerbun
"The goal is not to avoid feeling something. The goal is to make sure it's a round trip, not a one-way ticket."
- Betsy Butterick
2 QUESTIONS FOR YOUR TEAM
Q1: What is one thing you expected from this season that you have never actually said out loud to a coach or teammate?
Q2: When a practice or a game does not go the way you wanted, what helps you feel it, let it go, and get back to the next play?
1 RESOURCE TO GO DEEPER
Loving What Is by Byron Katie
JP brought Katie's four questions into the conversation, starting with "Is it true?" They give you a simple way to examine the shoulds behind your frustration with players, staff, your own kids, and yourself.
KEY TAKEAWAYS
1. Should is a trapdoor. Open it.
Nate calls should the S word because it sits on top of expectations we rarely examine. Betsy feels it as a stuck place: something we think ought to happen that has not, usually for a reason worth exploring. When you hear yourself say a player should know this or the team should be better, treat it as a signal to look underneath, not a verdict.
2. Ask whether it is true, then ask who you would be without it.
JP leans on Byron Katie's four questions. Is it true? Can I absolutely know it is true? How do I feel when I think this thought? Who would I be without it? Whether the should is true matters less than what it does to you. It keeps you tense and angry, and it gets in the way of the relationship, the right correction, and better teaching.
3. Hold the standard without living in the should.
Standards still matter. When a player is late, enforce the consequence you agreed on. What changes is the story in your head. Drop the narrative that they do not care and are ruining your practice, then get curious about what kept them from being on time and how you can help them get there next time.
4. When shoulds collide, listen and validate before you defend.
A senior expects to be captain. The coach runs a vote on clear criteria. That collision is what Betsy calls a should storm. Stop pointing fingers, validate the disappointment without agreeing, and resist the urge to defend. Then turn to what is still possible, like leading without a title in their final season.
5. Accept where you are so change can start.
Betsy's unforgettable food poisoning story at a Pac-10 tournament lands the point: nobody brings you new pants until you admit you need them. Nate adds the hard question every coach eventually faces: what is the reality I need to accept? Acceptance feels awful, but on the other side of it is calm, and that is where the change in your teaching, your perspective, or your approach begins.
6. Feel it, then come back.
Awareness is the first step for JP, followed by training new thoughts like gratitude and counting the gains instead of the gap. Betsy's rule is that emotion should be a round trip, not a one-way ticket, so let yourself feel the frustration, name it, and return. Nate gives players a simple in-the-moment tool: pair a deep breath with their intention for the day, like I want to get better and I am here to have fun.
ACTION ITEMS
CATCH YOUR SHOULDS
Jot down every should you think or say about a player, a staff member, or your team this week. Pick one and ask JP's question: is that true?
SAY THE QUIET PART
Write down one expectation you hold for your team that you have never actually said, then share it with the team before your next practice.
ASK WHAT THEY NEED
Ask one player in your next one-on-one, what do you need from me to be successful? Then say clearly what you can and cannot give.
TEACH A BREATHING RESET
Have each player name their intention for practice, then show them how to pair it with one deep breath when frustration hits.
Get notes and tools at tocculture.com
Get notes and tools at tocculture.com | Join TOC Coach - community, courses, and live coaching for coaches who want to go deeper. | Better Coaches. Better Leaders. Better Culture.