441: Mastery + Mattering: The Way of Excellence | Brad Stulberg Part 1

Podcast accessible on: iTunes | Spotify | YouTube

Excellence isn't just getting good at something—it's the intersection of mastery (concrete progress toward worthwhile goals) and mattering (feeling connected to something beyond yourself). As coaches, our job is to help athletes play two games at once: the finite game (winning this contest) and the infinite game (becoming a better person). When we only focus on one, we shortchange our athletes.

Key Takeaways

Reward effort, not just results. It's easy to say "process over outcomes" but only praise athletes when they play well. If you claim to value process, praise good effort regardless of what the scoreboard says. Your actions have to match your words.

Give every player a concrete role. The athlete who isn't getting playing time still needs to matter. Maybe they push starters in practice, bring energy to the locker room, or model a certain attitude. Make their contribution visible and specific—don't just tell them they matter, show them how.

Ask athletes what drives them. Some kids want to win. Some want to hang out with friends. Some just want to have fun. All valid. Your job isn't to impose your vision—it's to make sure each athlete gets what they came for within the framework of the team.

Set three types of goals: outcome, process, and person. Outcome = win the championship. Process = show up to every practice, execute the system. Person = confront your fear of failure, develop confidence, learn to contribute when you're not the best player. Most coaches skip the person goal entirely.

Start the season with parents by defining your three goals. Mastery (skill development), mattering (being part of a real team), and wanting to play again next year. If parents can't get behind that, help them find a different team. Set expectations early.

Don't overcorrect away from outcomes. Outcomes do matter. Winning matters. Pretending otherwise insults your athletes' intelligence. The point isn't to ignore results—it's to ensure the process and the person development happen alongside the pursuit of winning.

Build a brain trust around your highest-level athletes. At the pro or elite college level, there's enormous pressure and money at stake. Athletes need people in their corner who care about them as a person first—people who will hit the brakes if success starts sacrificing their soul or long-term health.

When purpose feels distant, come back to values. Some days you won't feel connected to your why. That's normal. Values are more concrete than purpose—consistency, integrity, authenticity. Even on bad days, you can act in alignment with your values. That's the process. Living on purpose is the outcome.

One Teaching Cue or Question

"What do you want to get out of this as a person?"

Use it when setting goals with individual athletes or the team. Push past bonus checks and stats. Get them thinking about who they want to become through the process of competing.

One Action Item

At your next team meeting, define your team's outcome goal, process goals, and have each athlete write down one personal goal—something about who they want to become, not just what they want to achieve. Collect them. Reference them throughout the season.

The Way of Excellence by Brad Stulberg: https://www.bradstulberg.com/

Join the TOC Coach Community for FREE: https://www.skool.com/toccoach/about

Subscribe to the Team Culture Toolbox Newsletter so you don’t miss the notes to this and every episode! https://tocculture.com/culture-toolbox

Learn More and Apply for the next TOC Coaching Retreat: https://www.tocculture.com/retreat
Learn More about Besty Butterick and her work with coaches! https://betsybutterick.com/